Sharri Markson:
All right, we can now bring you an exclusive new report that examines real wages, and it reveals real wages are now lower than 30 years ago, so lower now than they were in 1998. In inflation, therefore maybe in a real sense, a lot higher than Australians have been led to believe. This is an Institute of Public Affairs report and its author, Chief Economist, Adam Creighton joins me now. Great to see you, Adam.
Adam Creighton:
Thanks, Sharri.
Sharri Markson:
So tell us about your main finding about real wages and how they compare to 30 years ago.
Adam Creighton:
Yeah. Well, basically the top line finding is pretty staggering and scary really. And that’s if you put dwelling prices, house and apartment prices in the CPI, which of course are not in there, many people don’t realise that, that they’re not in there. The goods that most people in Australia would like to buy is not in the CPI. Now, if you do that at a relatively modest share, you realise that in 2025, real wages are 0.5% lower than they were in 1998. And if the share is a mere 15%, and that’s not a big share. So for instance, most people who buy a home are spending 30, 40% of their disposable income on home loan repayments, much more than 15%. But if you just make it 15%, then real wages are about 10% lower than they were in 1998.
Now, there’s no period in Australian history, Sharri, that I can think of. And I did this work with Gareth Aird, who’s a well known economist. There’s no period in Australian history over 28 years where real wages were 10% lower at the end than at the start. So you start to understand why people are angry, why they’re turning to other parties, why they’re furious, why they hate official statistics, because you’ll have Jim Chalmers out there saying, “Oh, real wages are growing.” But of course he-
Sharri Markson:
I was going to say, that is what he would say is his big success story but your casting doubt on that.
Adam Creighton:
That’s right, but he’s using the consumer price index to deflate the wage price index to be a bit technical. But that consumer price index doesn’t include stamp duty, it doesn’t include interest rates, it doesn’t include passports, actually I found out today, but most importantly, it does not include the cost of buying a home. It does not include it. The most important purchase of anyone’s life. And for people out there who are saying, “Oh, well, that’s just not how you do the CPI.” Well, frankly, from 1953 to 1983, the American CPI, the granddaddy of all CPIs, the oldest in the world, it included house prices for 30 years until 1983. And you know why they took them out in 1983? They took them out because they were rising too fast and the politicians hated the fact that the CPI [inaudible 00:02:45]-
Sharri Markson:
Right, so they were in there before 1983?
Adam Creighton:
Yes. In the United States, not in Australia, but in the US, the most important economy in the world, they were there. And then in the late ’70s, inflation spiked, house prices in the US started spiking. The Carter administration freaked out because all of their payments were indexed to the CPI and some very smart people got together and they decided, what’s the theoretically pure way we can get rid of house prices? And so they came up with a good one and it’s that house prices are an asset, so therefore they should not be in the consumer price index. They’re not a consumption. So that’s been very neat and nice, but that’s not the way you see prices. It’s not the way anyone on the street sees prices. And so no wonder when you tell people, and I hear this all the time, I say, “Oh, inflation’s 3.7%.” They’re like, “No, it’s not. It’s a lot more than that.” And that’s because subliminally in their head, they’re seeing what’s happened to house prices and they have gone up five times since 1998.
Sharri Markson:
Adam, the Reserve Bank’s Assistant Governor of Financial Markets, Christopher Kent has warned that we could be facing more rate hikes even if the economy slows because of the fuel crisis. Now, Adam explained this to me because I thought having fuel rising, it has a similar effect to a rate rise anyway, so why would you need the double up?
Adam Creighton:
Well, the problem there is the RBA is freaking out about inflation expectations. If you look at all their models, their mathematical models, one of the most important terms is inflation expectations. So not actual inflation, but what people think inflation will be. I mean, the problem is if people think inflation’s going to be five, then it has a tendency to be five. And the problem of what you’re seeing now is because it’s four already and it’s going to be five, if people start thinking, if businesses, ordinary people start thinking it’s going to be five, then they just automatically put up their prices by five. And that’s very scary to the RBA. So the problem for them is that they’re going to have to crush this expectation.
And it was interesting, just this week, Michele Bullock said, “Well, if we have to have a recession, we’re going to have to have one to get rid of inflation.” And we’re already on the case where the RBA is a bit of a joke. I shouldn’t say joke, but it’s not very hard on inflation, right? I mean, it’s very high now. They haven’t lifted rates very much, so they could a lot more to try to get it down. But of course, as you know, they had this dual mandate where they’re meant to look at employment as much as they look at inflation, which is impossible, some would say. But anyway, they’re in a real quandary because fuel prices in theory are not the Australian government’s fault. They’re not the reserve bank’s fault, right? It’s a global problem.
Sharri Markson:
But that’s the thing, Adam, I mean, if we do go into a recession, inflation was already high before the war, but of course the war will be blamed for it. It’ll be global factors. So there you go, it’s a get out of jail, free card perhaps. Adam Creighton-
Adam Creighton:
Well, look-
Sharri Markson:
Yeah, very quickly.
Adam Creighton:
Look, I was just going to say, of course, if there’s a real recession, you know what they’re going to do with rates, put them to zero. So at the end of the day, if it’s really bad, you can count on them going to zero. That’s what they always do.
Sharri Markson:
Great to have you.
This transcript of Adam Creighton on Sharri Sky News Australia from 26 March 2026 has been edited for clarity.
