Daniel Wild on The Rita Panahi Show News24 – 24 August 2026

Share this edition:

Rita Panahi:

Joining me now is Deputy Executive Director at the Institute of Public Affairs, Daniel Wild. Dan, the reaction of vice chancellors of university officials was a political and ideological decision that had nothing to do with free speech. If a far right group set up a similar encampment on campus, it’d be condemned and gone within the hour. I’m quite concerned that free speech is being used as an excuse for some of the actions we have seen in the last two, three years.

Daniel Wild:

Yeah, I think there’s a couple of things here. You’re right to say or to point to the double standards, which is really one of the key issues we’ve seen through this whole period. The universities are one example. We also have seen it in the failure of police, particularly in New South Wales and Victoria, to actually enforce the law. I mean, there’s plenty of laws that stop people intimidating and harassing other people and inciting violence, and quite rightly. Those laws should be enforced and enforced in a fair manner.

On the broader topic of freedom of speech, the issue here is that calling for limitations on freedom of speech will not only not stop antisemitism and other forms of socially divisive behaviour, but will actually result in the very groups calling for them being targeted themselves, i.e. Jewish groups. This is what’s happened for decades now. And all you have to do is look at section 18C of the Racial Discrimination Act and ask yourself, who has this been weaponized against?

Has this been used against any of those groups that have been engaging in antisemitism? No, it’s been used against Pauline Hanson. It’s been used against your colleague, Andrew Bolt. It’s been used against the late, great Bill Leak. Again, this is an example of a law that has been weaponized for political purposes. So unfortunately, this hatred we have in our society cannot be legislated away by fiat from Canberra. There is something very deep running through our society and having more anti-free speech laws or so-called anti-hate speech laws is not going to solve the problem.

Rita Panahi:

It’s not, but it seems to be the only solution we are getting from our leaders. And now to have Justice Jackman also questioning the fundamental human right of free speech, instead of pointing to the weak leaders, the leftist ideologues who are refusing to tackle antisemitism. And as you explained, there are existing laws that could be used to tackle this, particularly when threats are made and people are being openly intimidated.

Daniel Wild:

Yeah, that’s right. Look, I think what Justice Jackman’s getting at, and I didn’t see his whole speech or hear it, but I think he’s talking about the implied right of political communication, which is some important but somewhat abstract constitutional matter. I think when it gets to the brass knuckles of what people can and can’t do in their day-to-day lives, you’re quite right to point out it’s the weakness of political leaders. Also, the two-tier justice system that I point to.

I’ll also point you to comments by New South Wales premier Chris Minns, who made this probably a year ago or six months ago, where he basically said multiculturalism and freedom of speech are incompatible. In order to protect the interests and the sensitivities of different migrant groups, then we can’t actually have freedom of speech. We can’t have an open debate. And I though that comment was very revealing and actually very honest. I don’t know if Chris Means knew exactly what he was saying when he said it, but this is clearly a view. You can’t have multiculturalism and freedom of speech. And this is one of the defining issues of our time.

Rita Panahi:

Now, one nation leader Pauline Hanson has been forced to correct her own MP, David Farley, who told the ABC that immigration rates under one nation wouldn’t be too different to what Labour and the coalition are proposing. Here is what David Farley said on insiders.

David Speers:

It doesn’t sound like effectively if you’re talking about a number of 220 or 30 or 40,000. Is it that different to the government’s objective here? I know they’re not there yet, but they want to get it down to 225.

David Farley:

I think the big differences is we’re focusing on what are the skills we need as a nation? Where do we need these migrants to be-

David Speers:

But the raw number, the raw number is not too different.

David Farley:

Well, the raw number’s not too different, but the reality is where do we need them? We don’t need them in the great urban metroplex. We need them out to be productive, working in agriculture, engineering, mining, et cetera.

Rita Panahi:

Oh, dear. Now Pauline Hanson wrote on social media a few hours later that One Nation’s policy was to cut net overseas migration to 130,000. And is this damaging to One Nation and not the first time that David Farley has contradicted the party leader?

Daniel Wild:

Yeah, this is becoming a bit of an issue for One Nation, isn’t it? With David Farley, the first elected into the lower house for One Nation on his own bat. It sort of is cutting across, as you say, some policies there. Now, what’s interesting is in that tweet, Pauline Hanson says 130,000 net overseas migration. You go to their website, it’s got different information on there about visas issued and so forth. Now you can have more than one policy and more than one number, but I think it actually started as 130,000 gross intake and now they’ve changed it. I actually don’t know what the policy is anymore. And this is a really big issue for them, quite obviously, because immigration is the number one issue that is attracting Australians to vote for one nation. So for their own sake, they need to sort it out. They need to put a number out there. They need to stick to that number.

The other thing I’ll point you to, Rita, as well, something that we need to bring into the Australian debate is the experience of Canada. Now, I know you know about this, but Canada actually dramatically cut immigration to the point where it had negative population growth over several months last year. And so you can actually start to look at the Canadian experience and say, “Well, what happened there? Can we bring that model to Australia?” But while we have this debate, this sort of intractable debate about this number, that number, unfortunately, we’re not actually getting to the things that matter that much.

Rita Panahi:

Now, One Nation has also called for Section 18C of the Racial Discrimination Act to be removed, given that it’s a enduring threat to political debate and free speech. But again, David Farley didn’t agree.

David Farley:

It’s something that you would really want to think very carefully on of where are we going as a nation? And what does the character and the personality we want to portray?

David Speers:

Doesn’t sound like you’re…

David Farley:

Well, I’m not convinced that we need to go and change anything at the moment.

David Speers:

Yeah. Okay.

Rita Panahi:

Dan, these are fundamental issues of values. You can have people within a party who disagree on certain topics, but something like Section 18C within one nation, I would have thought you would have a shared belief system when it comes to something that fundamental. And let’s not forget, the liberals took that to an election, won in a landslide, and then failed to do what they promised.

Daniel Wild:

Well, that’s right. I don’t quite understand how David Farley could arrive at that view. If nothing else, given that his boss is being persecuted under that very provision. I mean, even if it’s just pure self-interest that got him to that conclusion, I’m perplexed by this on many different levels. And we’re just talking about section 18C. And look, you can debate all the different components of it, but I would point you to just one thing. It is not being used in any way remotely close to what any reasonable person could say is consistent with what it was intended to do. And I disagree with it completely, don’t get me wrong. But you just look at the double standard, the fact that it’s been weaponized for political purposes. That in and of itself is enough to say that this is a terrible law that needs to be repealed, let alone all of the very important chilling effects.

Because it’s only a small number of people that are directly persecuted under this law. But for every one person, there’s thousands of others that look at what’s happened to Pauline Hanson, Andrew Bolt, Bill Leak, and so forth. And they go, “I don’t want to be in that camp. I’m just going to keep my mouth shut.” Well, that’s not what we do in Australia. People are allowed to speak. And I would have though that’s pretty straightforward.

Rita Panahi:

And even people who have been exonerated, the process has been the punishment for them. They’ve had this hanging over their head, the stress of legal proceedings, having to seek counsel, all of this. And the case of those three university students in Queensland who were dragged through this system for the crime of pointing out that a indigenous only area within a university was segregation and they didn’t agree with it. That to me is just unforgivable how we could have cases like that and not have this law changed. Now, don’t forget the Fight for the Right documentary premieres on News 24 tomorrow night at 7:00 PM.

Now let’s move on to Labour being pushed to consider putting parents that are dependent on Centrelink and have drug and alcohol issues into mandatory rehab. It follows revelations the WA government failed to remove three Aboriginal children from their Port Hedland home where their mother killed them in a drug fueled rampage.

The Australian newspaper reveals the children’s grandmother warned authorities repeatedly about the risk her daughter posed and tried to have them live with her, but the children were not removed. She was ignored. Dorothy said her daughter would use welfare payments to fuel the drug habit that ultimately led to her crimes. Dan, we hear so little about these cases. These poor children, Jamelia, just 10 years old; Arnda, seven; and Kelvin, just four months old, were failed by their mother, but they were also failed by the system. Do you think the Albanese government should tie an addicted parent Centrelink payments to their commitment to at least undergo rehab?

Daniel Wild:

If it works, sure. I don’t know whether forced rehab is effective or not, to be honest with you. So look, I think these are always very complex in terms of what’s happening, these tragedies. And from what you described there, this may have been avoided if authorities had have granted custody to the grandparent. Now, maybe there’s good reasons they didn’t. I don’t know. So yeah, I mean, there’s a saying which is bad cases make bad law. So you don’t want to legislate on the basis of one case in and of itself. However, we do have some precedent in a sense, which is the cashless debit card, which is basically you’re going to be receiving welfare and payments in exchange for spending them on things that’s going to help your life rather than things that might make your life not as good. So it would probably be consistent with that principle and that concept.

But like I say, I don’t know whether forcing people into rehab is something that actually produces a better outcome for them or not. If it does, it should be looked at. But like I say, I think these tragedies are always very complicated at the local level.

Rita Panahi:

They are complicated, but speaking more broadly, I wonder if the debate that we need to have is why children in this circumstance were not removed, and whether the fact that they were indigenous played a part. Because we have heard from people working in that sector that there is a reluctance because of the spectre of the stolen generation, that they don’t want to create another one and remove indigenous children from their homes. And I think that is a debate that has almost, Dan, become taboo to have.

Daniel Wild:

Yeah, I think that’s a fair point. And I know Senator Jacinta Price has talked about these kind of matters with some authority about the unwillingness for that to happen, as you say, for ideological reasons. And so this is clearly something that needs to be addressed. If children are not being removed from a dangerous environment because of the factors that you have outlined, then plainly that is a monumental failure of the political system.

Rita Panahi:

Daniel Wild, thank you for your time.

This transcript of Daniel Wild on The Rita Panahi Show – News24 from 24 August 2026 has been edited for clarity.

Daniel Wild

Daniel Wild is a Deputy Executive Director at the Institute of Public Affairs
Stay up to date

Sign up to our newsletter to stay up to date with the IPA’s work

Support the IPA

If you liked what you read, consider supporting the IPA. We are entirely funded by individual supporters like you.

Related Posts

Margaret Chambers on Mornings with Graeme Goodings FiveAA – 9 November 2026

Graeme Goodings: Good morning. If you’ve just tuned in, thanks for dropping...

Andrew Bushnell on Ben Fordham Live 2GB – 9 November 2026

Ben Fordham: Controversial new powers will be in the spotlight today because...

Digital Duty of Care to usher in surveillance state and demolish privacy

“The digital duty of care model is unsalvageable, with a hidden amendment...

How the digital duty of care violates the right to privacy

Key Findings By expanding the powers of the eSafety Commissioner under national...