After being so bad for so long on freedom of expression, the Liberals are beginning to take seriously the erosion of the most basic of all human freedoms.
As one Liberal MP has put it, “The mystery is not why One Nation is polling at 25 per cent. The mystery is why they’re not polling more.”
Regardless of how One Nation performs at the upcoming South Australian and Victorian state elections, and then at the federal election, the party’s effect on national politics over the last few months of has been profound.
Of all the major political parties, the one that has most strongly and most consistently defended freedom of speech is One Nation.
Freedom of speech is something both the Labor and Liberal parties have, for their own reasons, consigned to the “culture wars” bucket in an effort to avoid talking about the topic.
The Labor Party has done so because, in common with similar political parties around the world, as soon as the left gained the cultural hegemony it currently enjoys, the ALP abandoned any commitment to freedom of speech.
Meanwhile, Liberal MPs, out of a combination of ignorance, naivety, and a belief that voters don’t care about it, refuse to engage with the issue.
The interesting thing is that there’s abundant evidence that increasingly, voters do care about freedom of speech.
“The drift of conservative voters has demolished the claim of Liberal moderates that ‘the base has nowhere else to go’.”
In the ANU Election Study conducted after last year’s federal election, respondents were asked what they thought the aims of Australia should be for the next 10 years. They were required to choose their top priority from four options and 17 per cent nominated “Protect freedom of speech”.
“Fight rising prices” was nominated as the top priority by 39 per cent of respondents. Revealingly, voters under the age of 25 were far more committed to protecting freedom of speech than those in their 30s and 40s.
Even before its first sitting day, a Labor senator was urging the antisemitism royal commission to recommend laws against “disinformation”, as Michelle Ananda-Rajah did in The Australian Financial Review earlier this month.
Thankfully, after being so bad for so long on freedom of speech, there are signs the Liberals are beginning to take the erosion of the most basic of all human freedoms seriously.
The new shadow communications minister, Sarah Henderson, this week called for an investigation of the powers of the eSafety commissioner to direct social media companies to censor what the public can say on social media.
This comes after the Full Federal Court found that the eSafety commissioner had acted unlawfully in attempting to get X (formerly Twitter) to remove a post criticising a Melbourne primary school for teaching radical gender ideology to eight-year-olds.
Henderson’s call is significant because the Coalition created the role of eSafety commissioner while in government, and it appointed and then re-appointed the current incumbent.
For the Liberals, the rise of One Nation led to the removal of opposition leader Sussan Ley. The drift of conservative voters from the Liberal Party to Pauline Hanson has demolished the claim of Liberal moderates that tilting their party to the left won’t have electoral consequences because “the base has nowhere else to go”. The Liberal “base” now does have somewhere else to go, and once it’s gone, there’s no guarantee it’s coming back.
The influence of One Nation’s polling numbers on the Labor Party isn’t quite as dramatic, but it is noticeable. It is difficult to imagine that six months ago, before One Nation’s surge and before Bondi, Anthony Albanese would have said he had “no sympathy” for the “ISIS brides”.
Similarly, it’s unlikely that a year ago a junior minister from the Socialist Left faction would have delivered a speech calling on progressives to support Australia Day, as Julian Hill did this week.
At this stage, there’s no reason to think anything the prime minister or Hill said is anything other than performative, but the fact that they felt the need to attempt to reflect something of the opinion of mainstream Australia is revealing.
As recently as May last year, ALP federal secretary Paul Erickson told the National Press Club that one of the reasons for the Labor Party’s landslide victory was that it avoided talking about the “culture wars”. Thanks to One Nation, it looks like that’s a strategy Labor has abandoned.
