Saxon Davidson on The Close Ausbiz – 5 October 2026

Share this edition:

Andrew Geoghegan:

Australia still has around 325,000 job vacancies with worker shortages remaining elevated across key sectors, including construction and manufacturing. To unpack the latest data, we’re joined now by the Institute of Public Affairs Research Fellow, Saxon Davidson. Saxon, welcome to you. How do you explain this mismatch then? If we have so many vacancies, why are we still seeing that? I’ll see you point out in fact that they’ve been at those levels for more than five years.

Saxon Davidson:

Yeah. So this initial worker shortage crisis was born out of the pandemic. Clearly it was quite a traumatic time, not only for our country, but for the world. And there were major economic shocks that occurred because of it. And there wasn’t the free movement of people that usually associate with a country like Australia. And hence there was elevated job vacancies. And unfortunately they’ve been at or above 325,000 people for the last five years and one quarter. And the government has no real solution at the moment to address this. And this has many consequences for the broader economy.

First and foremost, it’s foregone wages for Australians who are not working or filling these job vacancies. But also there’s the broader productivity issues arising from the fact that businesses simply don’t have the workers that they need to provide goods and services to the broader community. So that’s why it’s been elevated for the last five years and three months at or above 325,000 vacancies. And it’s having harsh effects on the entire economy, particularly because Australia is more or less at full employment at the moment. And so there are broader issues that come across with that as well in that we need to see genuine reform in order to see this fixed.

Andrew Geoghegan:

How do we reconcile that with historically high levels of immigration? Where are those new immigrants going or is it the fact that they perhaps don’t hold the skills necessary to fill those jobs?

Saxon Davidson:

Well, the latter point you just raised is one key aspect of it. There was recent research by the Institute of Public Affairs that found that less than half of the people that are coming to Australia on the skilled visa programme are actually skilled. And of those people that are skilled, they are often not in sectors of the economy that we need directly. Of course, there’s been a large controversy in the fact that there have been very few skilled visas being given to people who can work in construction, for example. But of course, skilled migrants and skilled people in the skilled visa programme are not the only people coming into Australia.

We’ve had a record migration programme largely because of things like international students who are not filling job vacancies. And if they are, they’re in low skilled labour. So that’s widely the reason. But also the government had justified the elevated migration levels that we’ve seen over the last four or so years. But due to the fact that we do and we did have these elevated job vacancy levels, you’d hear the prime minister raised it and was in multiple media releases in the fact that we need a elevated migration programme in order to fill these job vacancies. But it has simply not worked.

During the Albanese government’s first term in office, for every 10 net migrants that entered the country, only one net job vacancy was filled. So it’s simply not working and it’s turned into sort of a lazy solution in the fact that it has continued to not work because job vacancies are not usually this high. Before COVID, the average job vacancy level would range between about 180 and 190,000 job vacancies. And the fact that it is currently 325,000, a full five years or four years after the pandemic has ended, means that the current policy situation is not working for Australian businesses and is not working for the economy.

Andrew Geoghegan:

So actually you mentioned at least one sector there that’s feeling the shortage there most acutely is in construction. At a critical time, of course, when we’re looking, or the government has set that target of building 1.2 million homes by the end of the decade. And clearly labour shortages remaining a key hurdle to meet those forecasts. Just how severe is the shortage of labour in that sector?

Saxon Davidson:

Well, it is significantly higher than what it was before the pandemic. So the shortages in construction are about 20% higher now than what they were in February 2020. And that is maybe the fourth or the fifth highest in all the sectors of the economy. Manufacturing, which is another industry that’s key for our housing sector and to meet the housing accord is also significantly higher than it was in February 2020. Ever since the government announced the National Housing Accord, the 1.2 million homes by the end of the decade, if you average out the amount of houses that are needed every financial quarter, not one of those financial quarter targets have been met.

So clearly this is something that even though the government may aspire to have more homes, the fact that there’s been no genuine solution to our worker shortage crisis, particularly in the construction sector and particularly considering that skilled migrants who have entered the country, half of them are not skilled and the vast majority do not have skills in construction means that they’re not actually serious about fixing this problem.

Andrew Geoghegan:

I also see you point out that potentially the tax system is conspiring against them when we take a look at in particular pensioners and students who may well be discouraged from entering the workforce. How so?

Saxon Davidson:

So age pensioners and students on the youth allowance have this clawback, this ratchet clawback. So for pensioners, for every dollar that they earn over approximately a day and a half of minimum wage, they get 50 cents taken off their benefits. And because their combined income and their age pension is captured as taxable income, then they get the additional bottom bracket tax rate added on to that 50 cent clawback. So age pensioners as a result face an effective marginal tax rate of roughly 65 cents on the dollar for every dollar that they earn over a day and a half on minimum wage, which is simply unfair.

It’s unfair and also it discourages them from working. It discourages them from working post that day and a half on minimum wage. And students actually cop it far worse. So they have that day and a half of minimum wage, but once it reaches about two days on the minimum wage, students face a 60 cent clawback for every dollar earned over that amount. So it means that for pensioners, about 3% of Australian pensioners are currently in the workforce and that’s vital experience that we are missing from the economy. And for students, it’s experience that we are robbing them for genuine experience in the workforce and also an opportunity for them to be able to earn money while they are studying, particularly because students on the youth allowance are vulnerable people.

These are people who are poor and these are people who desperately need income and we are taxing them at 76 cents on the dollar. It’s brutally unfair. But the macro sense in this is that because we are at full employment roughly, it means that we actually need to entice people who are not in the labour force at all, not accounted in unemployment and not encountered in the employment rate. It means that we actually need to capture people who are not involved whatsoever in the workforce or the labour force, and we actually need to get them to enter in order to fill these job vacancies.

Andrew Geoghegan:

Well, I mean the question of course then, Saxon, is how you facilitate that? What reforms would be required in your view at the IPA there to address that gap?

Saxon Davidson:

So we’ve adopted the position for a long time is that we need to adopt the New Zealand sort of pension model to taxation. They apply obviously in New Zealand, in which that there is no clawback applied to age pensioners in New Zealand and that they just face the bottom rate tax rate and then obviously goes higher and higher as tax brackets do typically on your combined pension and your combined income. This is why one in four pensioners in New Zealand work compared to our measly 3%. And a pensioner in New Zealand working two days on minimum wage only faces a tax rate of 10.5% compared to here in Australia of 66. So our position is to adopt this tax rate to Australian pensioners, students on the youth allowance, and also to veterans on the service pension.

Andrew Geoghegan:

Saxon, great to get across those issues in regards to the shortfall in jobs. Thanks for joining us from Institute of Public Affairs.

This transcript with Saxon Davidson talking on The Close – Ausbiz from 5 October 2026 has been edited for clarity.

Saxon Davidson

Saxon Davidson is a Research Fellow at the Institute of Public Affairs.
Stay up to date

Sign up to our newsletter to stay up to date with the IPA’s work

Support the IPA

If you liked what you read, consider supporting the IPA. We are entirely funded by individual supporters like you.

Related Posts

Problem with PM’s golf club grant is Canberra has too much money

Too much easy money at the federal level leads to wasteful spending....

Trump should shore up his legacy and make way for Vance

Donald Trump’s greatest remaining service to the America First movement might be...

Daniel Wild on Credlin News24 – 4 November 2026

Steve Price: Welcome back. Steve Price with you. Coming up, Peter’s favourite,...

Surviving North Korea: One Woman’s Story of Escape from Communist Tyranny

This is the extraordinary story of Young (Choi Geum-hyeong), who escaped North...