“If you don’t read the newspaper, you’re uninformed. If you do, you’re misinformed,” is commonly attributed to Mark Twain. Whatever its provenance, it’s wholly accurate when it comes to the breathless nonsense that accompanies any change in official rates by the Reserve Bank, or any other central bank for that matter.
Three eminent economists, Jeff Borland, Peter Dawkins and Ross Garnaut, recently took Australian Financial Review columnist Richard Holden to task in print for accusing the RBA of politicising monetary policy by downplaying the impact of public spending growth on inflation.
I’d like to take them to task for believing movements in the cash rate shifts inflation or unemployment in any observable or even meaningful way. It’s at best a theory without any serious evidence to support it.
In an exclusive interview last week with Hoover Institution senior fellow John Cochrane, one of the world’s top macro and financial economists for many years, I modestly suggested that “small moves in the cash rate could not have any kind of statistically tangible effect on the growth rate of the CPI”.
He went much further. “Let me tell you honestly, we don’t really know if higher interest rates raise inflation or lower inflation,” he responded. “I can tell you, it’s not even a theory, it’s a story.”
The idea basically relies on one data point: the 1980s. “Central banks raised interest rates and inflation came down, but 10 other things happened, too,” Cochrane said, pointing to Reagan’s presidential win, then massive spending cuts. “We fixed Social Security. We cut marginal tax rates from 70 per cent to 28 per cent. So, one episode is always dodgy.”
Another myth peddled around “rates day” is how low unemployment is supposedly inflationary. Yet inflation has been high when unemployment is high or low, rising or falling. It was rampant in the 1970s even as unemployment surged. It was subdued in the late 1990s and 2010s, despite labour markets tightening to levels once thought impossible. Japan has combined near-full employment with near-zero inflation for decades.
Moreover, the very definition of unemployment is arbitrary. The ABS said on Thursday the jobless rate had risen to 4.3 per cent in February, from 4.1 per cent a month earlier. But that definition excludes the near one million potential workers who say they want a job but either haven’t searched recently or aren’t available right away.
Roy Morgan’s far more realistic measure showed that in the same week what it calls the “real unemployment rate” fell to 10.6 per cent from 11.2 per cent in January. So is unemployment currently inflationary or deflationary? Pick your measure.
The reverence accorded official pronouncements is similarly laughable. Since 2012 Australia’s trimmed mean inflation, the one the RBA supposedly cares most about, has been outside the already quite wide 2-3 per cent inflation target for almost nine years, or more than 60 per cent of the time.
In May 2021, the brightest minds at Treasury and the Reserve Bank, using the latest economic models, forecast inflation would never exceed 2.25 per cent across the next three years. Yet within 12 months it had jumped to 6.6 per cent before peaking at 7.8 per cent in late 2023.
And all these were published after governments had pumped Covid stimulus into their economies. Indeed, they were made after inflation had already begun to rise rapidly, and they occurred well before Russia invaded Ukraine in early 2022.
Isn’t it obvious from the Covid years that the money supply, which almost no one talks about, has a far bigger impact on inflation than fiddling with overnight interest rates? Unemployment and inflation both soared everywhere from 2021, another major crack in the idea they are necessarily related.
Not enough people understand that inflation mainly arises from money creation by the banking system through (mainly home) lending, and governments via deficit spending.
More than a quarter of all the Australian dollars in existence were created in the past five years. M3, the broadest measure of money, in Australia grew at around 7.3 per cent, to $3.37 trillion, over the year to January, faster than any other relevant economic variable.
No wonder Australia’s inflation rate, at 3.8 per cent, was the highest in the 38-nation OECD before the war in the Middle East broke out, apart from Turkey, Colombia and handful of former Soviet bloc countries.
At least awareness is spreading. New shadow treasurer Tim Wilson on Wednesday said something no senior mainstream politician has said for years, when asked about inflation. “It’s too much money chasing too few goods. So what we have is more cash going into the economy than our economy is productively producing,” he told ABC radio.
We’re supposedly a free-market economy, yet one of the most important prices is set by bureaucrats who have for decades demonstrably failed to control inflation in the way they say they can. Why do perfectly sensible economic arguments about the folly of government pricing petrol or restaurant meals not apply to interest rates?
“Central banks have two masters,” Cochrane also explained to me. “One is the government, and the other is the banking system. Central banks do hold interest rates down to help governments finance deficits until the inflation gets really bad.”
Perhaps inflation hasn’t been mismanaged by officials who privately understand it, but managed for different ends.
