Cutting public spending has rightly become one of the foremost demands of sensible people.
Government borrowing costs are soaring the world over in developed nations, including Australia, where the federal government, let alone the states, is facing record 5.5 per cent interest rates to issue long-term bonds. Public interest payments threaten to swamp tax collections and trigger a global financial crisis that will put 2008 in the shade.
So it’s disappointing to see a subset of otherwise sensible people shriek in protest at attempts to cut federal spending where the beneficiaries happen to be perceived political allies. Take the outcry over the Australian Taxation Office’s perfectly reasonable refusal to pay credit card fees following the Reserve Bank’s bizarre decision to ban surcharging. I don’t want the government borrowing another $200m a year at near 6 per cent interest rates to subsidise the 10 per cent or so of small businesses who want to rack up frequent-flyer points on their tax payments.
Credit card cut
I was stunned credit cards were even an option to pay tax in the first place. As much as I hate our obviously excessive taxation, what’s Caesar’s shouldn’t be frittered away before it’s due.
Why should ordinary PAYG taxpayers subsidise business-class upgrades? Yes, some businesses use cards to manage cash flow. That’s an argument for arranging finance, not presenting the financing costs to everyone else.
I worked at the RBA in the early 2000s when the bank, in a world first, regulated to encourage businesses to pass on the costs of accepting credit cards. Domestic debit payments were generally much cheaper, being a few cents regardless of transaction size. Why the reversal 20 years later is beyond me. But the ATO shouldn’t be blamed for seeking an obvious saving within the regulatory environment it now faces.
Private health rebate
That’s not the only government expenditure beloved by normally sensible voters.
The Albanese government’s attempt to remove the extra private health insurance rebate for older Australians, saving a forecast $3bn over four years, has provoked extraordinary outrage. The Coalition and crossbench effectively blocked the legislation in the Senate this month.
The proposal would have increased the cost of private health insurance for over-65s by about $5 a week. To be sure, the PHI rebate wouldn’t be removed for seniors, but available only at the same income-based percentage reductions as for younger Australians.
Why should a younger worker receive less assistance than an older person with the same income? And why should Australians who aren’t fortunate enough to live beyond 65 be compelled to pay additional tax during their working lives to fund a subsidy they will never receive? To be sure, plenty of older Australians struggle, but so too do younger people, who typically have far less wealth.
Households headed by people aged 65 and over have around three times the net wealth (almost $1.5m) of those aged 25-40, according to the Grattan Institute in 2025. Indeed, retirees have other aged-based birthday presents to look forward to: recall that earnings on superannuation assets are generally tax-free from age 60, a very significant reduction from the 15 per cent earnings tax younger people pay while they are saving to retire.
Veterans benefits
There’s a third savings effort that’s prompted even greater fury; an attempt to cap at $5000 a year on physiotherapy, psychology and podiatry visits for veterans who have not been seriously injured in battle.
This would apparently have saved the federal government $750m over three years, and ended the prevailing arrangement of unlimited public payments for “allied health visits”, regardless of their efficacy.
A few years ago it was common to hear support for the very sensible idea of co-payments for all Medicare services, including GP visits, of at least a few dollars, which would have saved taxpayers many billions of dollars.
Understandable respect for veterans cannot mean every existing medical payment arrangement is beyond reproach. Asking whether treatment remains appropriate is hardly an insult. Indeed, Australian servicemen and women are almost the best paid in the world by a significant margin for their sacrifices.
Without reasonable scrutiny, governments risk rewarding the volume of appointments rather than improvements in health.
None of the above savings will go ahead, meaning the federal government will borrow billions of dollars more in coming years at potentially up to 6 per cent interest if recent financial market trends continue, a bill that will fall on younger generations.
These savings would be very low down my priority list, given the vast and obscene waste federal and state governments sustain, but they are savings nonetheless. Politicising Labor’s proposed savings for base political reasons means few if any savings will ever occur, ensuring Australia goes further down the South American path.
When “conservative” forces win government and seek to trim spending that benefits their political opponents, they can expect the same hysterical reaction. The gross hypocrisy only further erodes the respect younger voters have for the Coalition and Labor parties too.
