Sharri Markson:
And now to discuss, joining me former Labour State Secretary, Cameron Milner and Chief Economist at the Institute of Public Affairs, Adam Creighton. Great to see you both. Well, Adam, I mean, this money is already, it’s on top of the fact that COP is already costing taxpayers $150 million. Now this extra four million, and people, many families can barely afford to put food on the table.
Adam Creighton:
Yeah. Personally, I think the Labour Party would be thanking its lucky stars that it’s not actually hosting this meeting in Australia. So Chris Bowen has the presidency, but it’s being held in Turkey because people just don’t care enough about net zero anymore. And 4.2 million for 5-star hotels for foreigners, not even Australian politicians is just extraordinary. And sadly, this story is not getting as much attention as the so-called scandal with Pauline Hanson holidaying with Gina Rinehart, which of course costs absolutely nothing for the taxpayer. So this is the real scandal, snouts in the trough. So I think this will come back to bite the Labour government.
Sharri Markson:
Yeah. And it’s also being spent on a climate conference when people are more worried about how they’re going to pay their bills. I mean, Cameron, I know you often defend your buddy, Chris Bowen, but you’d have to agree that voters would think this is outrageous and out of touch.
Cameron Milner:
Well, I don’t think so. I think we have to be involved in the climate debate. We’re actually a country which can actually be heavily affected by the climate change. And that’s why as a host nation, which we are jointly with Turkey, we’re joint hosts, we’re going to spend money and we’re going to spend money being a host actually having these conversations before we go to the conference in August. So no, I think this is money well spent. This is money that we’re going to have to spend as a host nation. And to your point, Adam, I mean, we were probably in for 300 million, 50 million potentially as a host nation had it gone to Adelaide. But obviously split the cost as a co-host. And this is simply the cost of the business of being a host for COP.
Sharri Markson:
Well, Australia didn’t have to be a host for COP. It was just that Chris Bowen was desperate for the title of presidency, was desperate for the prestige. But Adam, what’s your response there to Cameron saying this is money well spent?
Adam Creighton:
Well, look, I just don’t think it is. I think that’s a bit of a laughable statement. Most people would think it’s not money well spent. It’s just a reminder that federal government is so vast, spending $820 billion every year, that each dollar is somewhat meaningless when it’s spent. And you just get this sort of extraordinary waste, which most people would be shocked at if they knew about. I mean, I briefly worked in government opposition and I was shocked when I worked there of what money was spent on. And I’m sure it was a lot worse then because the amount of spending back then was half what it is now.
Sharri Markson:
But Adam, this spending of course, contributes to inflation.
Adam Creighton:
Yes, it certainly does. And we have the highest core inflation rate in the Western world, which is extremely embarrassing. 3.6%, 3.8% and rising. That’s a serious problem. That’s been all those people out there on low wages. 4% of their wage every year is shrinking in value.
Sharri Markson:
I mean, Cameron, you’d have to admit, even if you personally think this is a good idea, you’d have to admit that the average Australian would be pretty angry at this.
Cameron Milner:
Well, I think it’s all in proportion, isn’t it? I mean, there’s a lot of government expenditure that, to Adam’s point I think, we can all agree is wasteful. There’s a huge care economy. Aged care, childcare, NDIS, massive, massive, billions of dollars being spent there. But as I say, I mean, we chose as a nation to be a co-host. This is a reasonably modest budget in terms of what it was otherwise going to cost us as a nation to do it in total. Turkey is bearing probably more than half being actually the physical host nation. And so look, if we want to be involved in the climate change debate, we want to be a host nation, which I think we should be because we should have a seat at the table. It’s going to cost some money to be invested into that process.
Sharri Markson:
All right, let’s move on now. Former RBA Governor Philip Lowe has warned that interest rates are likely to remain higher for longer. Philip Lowe said that inflation has been too high for too long. We’ve got this structural element coming from unit labour costs. And now he says we’ve got this cyclical element coming from the oil shock. So he says it’s understandable that the bank will have to keep interest rates relatively high for a fairly long period of time. Now Adam, Philip Lowe has been very critical of the Albanese government’s handling of the economy since he left. Quite extraordinary in a sense to know what he really thinks of the government seeing as he stood there alongside them for so long for the time that he was RBA governor. But in that statement, he’s very specifically not only blaming the Iran war.
Adam Creighton:
Yeah, Phil Lowe’s unusual because most former governors don’t really say anything, but he has certainly said a few things since he’s retired and they have indeed been very critical of the government. He said things that I agree with. I mean, just as I said earlier, we have the highest core inflation rate in the world. We’ve had five years, I believe, of falling real wages. Household income’s also been falling. We’ve basically had the worst economic performance in the OECD. We’re the only country, I think, where the inflation rate’s going up. There’s a 20% chance that next month the RBA will put up the interest rates. That’s going to be more pain. I think you’re going to see a big fall in house prices. You can say that’s good or bad depending on what position you’re in. But I think the country’s not being well managed. We’ve had the fastest increase in the size of the federal government since the Whitlam era. And it’s going to be faster still if we don’t cut spending on NDIS, which I seriously don’t think we will.
Sharri Markson:
And Cameron, even the current IBA governor, Michele Bullock, says that inflation was too high before the Iran war. We were in a worse position than most other countries.
Cameron Milner:
Well, it’s true. And I think that’s what’s often forgotten. I mean, the governments have amnesia before the Iran conflict, but no, we had runaway inflation, which was to your point, Adam, different from the rest of the world. The rest of the world had started to contain it. We still had out of control inflationary pressures in our economy because we haven’t got productivity right. We’ve got out of control government spending, out of control taxation and lax and lazy productivity in our country. That’s fundamentally our problem as a nation. I mean, we aren’t punching above our weight the way we used to. And we have got domestic inflation that is caused by government policy and government settings and the inability of the government to actually tackle it. So the interest rates are going to be higher for longer in Australia because the government’s been weaker for longer, fighting the really fundamental issues here in Australia.
Sharri Markson:
All right, let’s come back to the story of the moment. Pauline Hanson of course, fascinating leaked emails today. Now Pauline, as you know, has come under fire for meeting with controversial far right figure Tommy Robinson. I mean, he cost Karl Stefanovic his job, but now there’s controversy over who actually organised Pauline’s podcast interview with Tommy Robinson. Now it seemed, if you were watching Seven Spotlight programme, it seemed like Pauline Hanson or her team had organised it because Liam Bartlett was pretty tough on her about her decision to meet with him.
Liam Bartlett:
Do you think being associated with a person like you is a disadvantage for her electoral success or otherwise?
Tommy Robinson:
I need to be …
Sharri Markson:
And he grilled Pauline during Spotlight as well about her decision to do the interview with Tommy Robinson. But then Pauline’s chief of staff, James Ashby, has accused Seven of setting up the meeting. And here’s what Ashby told Paul Murray.
James Ashby:
I could send you the itinerary for the trip. It didn’t include Tommy. When Nigel Farage stepped down, there was a moment there where the producer, Luke Mortimer, was quite concerned that the whole trip was wasted because Nigel obviously stepped back into campaign mode and cancelled his meeting. And then the suggestion came from Channel Seven who I had given the contact of Tommy Robinson to. They lined it all up. They paid for the studio.
Sharri Markson:
So he said there, the suggestion came from Channel Seven. Now Channel Seven denies this. They’ve told news.com.au that that decision was made by One Nation and despite Barnaby Joyce’s suggestions, her podcast recording with Robinson was organised before the Spotlight crew knew about it. So Adam, look, a bit of tit-for-tat here, but leaked emails as well One Nation has put out and One Nation has now called the programme a stitch up. Pauline wasn’t happy with it. But look, it has set the agenda the whole week. So it’s good publicity for her, isn’t it?
Adam Creighton:
Yeah, certainly that’s what I think. Look, I don’t think it matters whether she met him or not. I mean, the fact is he’s a politically very powerful person in the UK, has a lot of support. I mean, I’m no fan of him, but most Australians wouldn’t even know who he is. So I mean, I think this will just … By this time next week, no one will be talking about this. I don’t think it really matters much for Pauline Hanson. People are going to like her regardless of whether she met Tommy Robinson. He has been convicted of crimes. I think he’s done time in jail. He’s a pretty unsavoury character, but I’m sure if you trawl through the history of Australian politics, you’ll find people that have gone to jail and not gone to jail who Australian MPs that they’ve associated with, they’ve married or whatever, and then they’ve been accepted back into society again. So we can’t be too hypocritical, but look, my main point is it’s not going to affect her.
Sharri Markson:
Well, I think if it affects her, it just gives her more publicity. It’s positive for her, all of this. But Cameron, what do you think? You’re a very experienced, well-respected Labour operative. I mean, Pauline is far from the most articulate or polished politician, not even the smartest. So what is it that’s really appealing and cutting through to voters?
Cameron Milner:
Well, it’s authenticity. It’s authenticity in the moment where you’ve got a stuffed shirt toff running the Liberal Party and an absolute liar running the Labour Party. I mean, that’s the choice that Australian voters have got at the moment. Between those two, you’re going to pick someone with authenticity. And I think that’s the thing that’s coming through to your point in the editorial. I mean, she’s going to be on a lot more scrutiny around policy and politics and a position like the Robinson stuff. And I think it’s a bit messy today with the back and forth of Channel Seven. They’ve got to get their processes better. But to your point, I think a lot of people, a lot of voters won’t know who Tony Robinson is, won’t care about it, but they’re looking for genuine choice and she’s offering it. And I like the fact that she speaks straight down the barrel of the camera and she says things that they think.
Sharri Markson:
And Cameron, do you think she’s here to stay as the more dominant force rather than the coalition until the next election?
Cameron Milner:
I certainly feel that way. And certainly if you look at the UK experience where reform, despite a couple of things, has stayed well ahead of the conservatives in terms of the politics over there. The same way the MAGA movement is well ahead of the Republicans in the US as well. I think these populist right votes actually stay with the leaders and stay with the people who are leading those groups like Pauline will in Australia rather than traditional sort of Tweedledee and Tweedledum that we’ve seen from the traditional political parties.
Sharri Markson:
Yeah. So it’s that appeal of a popular or charismatic leader who has cut through rather than the actual party where the memberships are falling. All right, Cameron Milner, Adam Creighton, great to see you both. Thank you.
This transcript with Adam Creighton talking on Sharri Sky News Australia from 21 July 2026 has been edited for clarity.
