In this interview, Morgan Begg appeared on FiveAA Mornings with Graeme Goodings to discuss the IPA’s research on migration.
All media appearances posted onto the IPA website are directly related to the promotion and dissemination of IPA research.
Below is a transcript of the interview.
Graeme Goodings:
Well, this programme and 2GB’s Ben Fordham were taken to task on Media Watch earlier this week on what Media Watch says were false claims that 1,544 migrants were arriving in Australia every day this year.
The ABS puts out two key migration figures. Net overseas migration, or NOM, is the official number and counts people who actually stay in Australia for 12 out of 16 months. It’s accurate, but it’s delayed.
Then there’s net permanent and long-term arrivals, or NPLT, which tracks what people say they intend to do. And now it’s quicker, but it’s less precise.
Now, while the two numbers differ in method, they’re usually closely linked. NPLT often gives an early clue to where NOM is heading.
I revised the sums and I took back the 1,544 figure, but the concrete latest net overseas migration figure was in excess of 900. So there are still more than 900 migrants coming into Australia each day, a point that the people on Media Watch didn’t bother to mention.
Well, the source of our story was the Institute of Public Affairs. Joining us now is IPA Director of Research, Morgan Begg.
Morgan, good morning to you.
Morgan Begg:
Morning, Graeme. Great to be with you.
Graeme Goodings:
Yeah, it’s great to have you on. So you want to take the ABC and Media Watch to task?
Morgan Begg:
Oh, I think it’s necessary. I think it’s extraordinary what’s occurred here.
You’ve laid out the facts very well. The fact is that whether it’s net overseas migration or permanent long-term arrivals, the numbers are highly correlated, and the net permanent long-term arrivals is an indicator of those migration trends.
And the Centre for Population, which is a government agency, even explicitly states this as well, that it’s an early indicator of future migration flows. So if the numbers are good enough for them, then it’s good enough for us.
And what we’re really worried about is it appears that the ABS is really stepping beyond their brief here. There’s a high level of trust that the Australian population has with the Australian Bureau of Statistics because they’re collecting data about us, and this is guiding policymaking. But what they’re doing here very much has the perception of doing the government’s work in attacking critics.
Graeme Goodings:
Yeah, I mean, you’ve accused the government effectively of weaponizing the ABS and conspiring with the ABC.
Morgan Begg:
Well, we’re just looking at what’s actually happening now. We were contacted behind the scenes by the ABS.* Others, such as yourself, Ben Fordham and others were also contacted by the ABS. And why? It’s very peculiar why they’re doing this.
The ABS themselves, in their descriptions of the methodology, acknowledge that these measures are closely linked and are leading indicators of each other. And the question is, okay, if it’s good enough for them, then it’s good enough for us to talk about.
[* Morgan was referring to the IPA being contacted by media outlets who were contacted by the ABS. The IPA was not contacted by the ABS directly.]
Graeme Goodings:
So when it comes back to the nitty-gritty, and we were saying that 1,544 people were arriving in Australia every day this year, do you stand by that?
Morgan Begg:
Oh, absolutely.
So here’s the thing. The net permanent long-term arrivals is the only data we have, and the ABS is talking about, well, there’s net overseas migration. That’s great, but that’s only up till the December 2024 quarter. Now they release monthly data for net permanent long-term arrivals monthly, and we have that up until July of this year.
So we’re talking about an issue that the community is deeply concerned about, which is the volume and the scale of arrivals to this country. And the only data that is available to us is net permanent and long-term arrivals. And the 1,500 that has been cited and is going around is accurate to that data.
Graeme Goodings:
Yeah. Well, net permanent long-term is an early indicator as you’ve conceded. So how reliable is it historically been in predicting the NOM?
Morgan Begg:
It’s usually very closely aligned. They track very closely to each other. Some years the net permanent and long-term arrivals is more than the net overseas migration figure. In some years, it’s lower. So I believe last year the net permanent long-term arrivals was more than net overseas migration. But in the years before that, it was the other way around.
So it all sort of comes out even over time. There’s just some variation year-by-year.
Graeme Goodings:
Why do you believe that the Centre for Population’s recognition of net permanent long-term figures has been ignored in the debate?
Morgan Begg:
Maybe the ABS or the government is uncomfortable with this debate, and so they’re ignoring inconvenient facts like that.
But I’ll just say this. I’m sure that for the government that they’re very uncomfortable about this debate that’s taking place, but their discomfort is paled in comparison to the discomfort felt in the community, who are on the receiving end of a migration programme that is completely out of control.
We’ve seen, since 2022, migration has been 350,000 people above government forecasts over the period. And in the same amount of time there’s been a housing shortage due to the migration intake of 180,000 homes.
Australians are copping it because the government is not managing and controlling the migration programme at a sustainable level.
Graeme Goodings:
You’ve linked high migration to housing affordability, economic stagnation and social division. Do you have strong evidence to back up those claims?
Morgan Begg:
Well, as I said, I mean, the migration has been above the government’s forecast. We’ve identified that there’s at least 180,000 shortage on housing supply, well, due to the demand, additional demand from migration.
Since 2022, we’ve seen negative per capita economic growth. That means while the economy is growing at the aggregate level, every Australian is getting a smaller and smaller slice of the economic pie over time. We’re seeing the additional strain on public services, whether it’s hospital waiting times or education, classroom sizes.
Across the board, this period since 2022, in which we’ve taken 1.3 million migrants on net terms at least, has led to very serious and obvious consequences for the Australian people.
It’s just simple supply and demand in many cases. You add more people to the equation, then you either need to increase supply or prices go up, and you bring about shortages. It’s just a simple fact of economics.
Graeme Goodings:
But there are some benefits in migration, aren’t there, for the economy?
Morgan Begg:
Well, I mean, it very much depends on whether you’re running a well-run migration programme. But we’re seeing in recent years that productivity is going down, per capita economic growth is going down so we’re actually not… And the job vacancy, so we’ve had a protracted job vacancy challenge in Australia for the last few years, and it’s still above 300,000 job vacancies according to the latest data so we’re bringing in…
The traditional argument for why you might have migration is because, well, there’s jobs that need to be filled, but the issue is we’re actually job vacancies are stagnant where they’re still at elevated levels. So clearly, we’re not attracting or we’re not bringing in the sort of migrants that the economy would actually need in which we could actually benefit.
Graeme Goodings:
Do you have a view, or does the IPA have a view on what migration policy changes you’d like to see implemented?
Morgan Begg:
Well, I’ll tell you one thing is at the current policy setting, that’s simply not acceptable, and they’re not acceptable as far as it relates to the opinions of the community.
We run a survey some time ago, which found that two-thirds of Australians would be happy to temporarily halt the migration, all programme altogether until housing and jobs and the social infrastructure had time to catch up to the demands from the recent intake.
I think there’s some merit to the idea. Let’s have a pause and let’s consider, well, what is the actual number that the community can handle and then go from there. Rather than trying to play catch-up, let’s just think, let’s get back to the drawing board and figure out what is the actual number and plan ahead for what we are prepared to take in.
Graeme Goodings:
I think it was during the last budget that the government suggested it would definitely reduce migration. Do you think they’ve, in fact, gone the other way? I mean, migration is higher than it has been before?
Morgan Begg:
I think there’s definitely the permanent long-term arrivals data is indicated that in the first six months of this year was higher than the first six months of 2024 on that measure. So as an early indicator, that might tell us that migration is actually going in the wrong direction. Well, we’ll know over time, as the ABS releases more data, exactly what the numbers are.
I do take issue. I think every year the government budget put out a number that they think is reducing migration. And then as I said before, over the last three years has been the actual net [inaudible 00:10:10] data, net overseas migration has been 350,000 more than the budgets actually forecast. So they have very poor track record of actually getting that right.
Graeme Goodings:
Morgan Begg, thanks for your time today.
Morgan Begg:
Appreciate it, Graeme.
Graeme Goodings:
Morgan Begg, IPA Director of Research.
This transcript with Morgan Begg talking on FiveAA Mornings with Graeme Goodings from 27 August 2025 has been edited for clarity.
